id
stringlengths
36
36
input
stringlengths
251
5.5k
expected_output
stringlengths
47
65
metadata.query_id
stringlengths
23
41
metadata.split
stringclasses
1 value
2dd8ec63-d300-4a7a-97f2-7f7052477d6a
The Settlements are seen by Palestinians as a sign of bad faith on the part of Israel, and therefore weaken the hand of Pro-Peace elements As important as the existence of the settlements themselves is their continued growth. The very fact that Israel has continued to ostensibly negotiate for the independence of a Pal...
[{"id": "test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro03a
test
a2c8761c-6093-4ed6-aba8-406da414dee2
Assange is mostly interested in self-promotion, not being a serious journalist. Journalists are judged by far more than their ability to acquire and disseminate knowledge or information. The quality of their writing, the skills and contacts developed to acquire it, the training used to enter the trade (which incidenta...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con01a
test
b3f37fa8-7f5a-4a3e-90d3-54f80d8eb1e7
Animal research causes severe harm to the animals involved The point of animal research is that animals are harmed. Even if they don’t suffer in the experiment, almost all are killed afterwards. With 115 million animals used a year this is a big problem. Releasing medical research animals in to the wild would be dange...
[{"id": "test-science-eassgbatj-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-science-eassgbatj-pro02a
test
ff13824d-b9eb-4e48-8668-4bc1e4c9c4bd
Animals shouldn’t be harmed The difference between us and other animals is a matter of degree rather than type [2]. Their bodies resemble ours, as do their ways of conveying meaning. They recoil from pain, appear to express fear of a tormentor, and appear to take pleasure in activities; a point clear to anyone who has...
[{"id": "test-science-eassgbatj-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-science-eassgbatj-pro01a
test
d6472037-669e-4501-af2f-7e9495230b62
The Settlements are illegal, and demonstrate the impotence of the international community The Settlements, constructed on land that is neither recognizably Israel’s nor which Israel has even claimed to annex are illegal, encroaching on the territory of a future Palestinian state. It is absurd for the international co...
[{"id": "test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro01a
test
e0317f21-51e3-41a7-b8ba-a97f487f2d9e
The Settlements commit future Israeli governments to a harder stand in future negotiations Whether deliberate or not, the settlements are changing the “facts on the ground” by changing the political calculus for future Israeli governments. While most Israeli politicians accept the need to abandon some smaller settlem...
[{"id": "test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-rmelhrilhbiw-pro02a
test
f65b07e2-4751-44fa-97cb-0c6fee8ffd0f
It is a basic principle of journalism that sources should be checked and verified by another, independent, source. British Foreign Secretary William Hague has pointed out that the actions of Wikileaks put British lives at risk. [1] Congressman Peter King described the mass leaking of documents as “Worse even than a ph...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con02a
test
6d0f8da2-a470-467f-b70b-b221f71311d4
Censorship is fundamentally incompatible with the notion of free speech. Censoring particular material essentially blinds the public to a complete world view by asserting the patronising view that ordinary citizens simply cannot read extreme material without recognising the flaws in it. This motion assumes that those ...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-con01a
test
8d51202d-1893-4fdb-a095-2ec34f633585
People often react poorly to being censored by their governments. In countries that do currently practice censorship of Internet information, their citizens often interpret this as suspicious and dictatorial behaviour. For example, in China growing discontent with the government’s constant censorship has led to public...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-con03a
test
8c88323a-e7b8-48cd-8778-d2d571b3b61a
An amnesty policy will serve only to alienate regimes, shutting down the possibility of discourse or reform It is a natural conclusion that a repressive regime, which operates largely by force and the control of its population, will react rather negatively to an action by the West that appears to be a calculated, publ...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con01a
test
1b97d310-c192-4247-8e1e-40c0166704d9
There is a difference between actual journalists and those who like having their names published in newspapers. Assange has far more claim to the description than many of them. One of the things that the Leveson Inquiry [1] has made all too apparent is that simply working for a newspaper or broadcaster is not a satisf...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro03a
test
5c32139b-573a-4d06-b3bc-4f57397394f2
The offer of amnesty allows home governments to discredit bloggers and paint them as foreign agents of disruption When Western states and democracies offer amnesty to bloggers under threat from their home governments, the blogger’s views and comments immediately become coloured in the eyes of the public. The governmen...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con03a
test
585692d8-8310-4d63-9fc3-d770bd7c0709
The concept of what is a journalist needs to be clarified to deal with the reality of new forms of mass communication. Assange gathers, collates and disseminates information, ergo, he is a journalist. Few industries have been changed more radically by the advent of the Internet than journalism. The traditional role of...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro01a
test
ad4e5651-0ae7-44eb-89f2-d4aeb669be89
Democracies should be wary of meddling in the internal affairs of other countries Authoritarian countries tend to guard their sovereignty jealously and will not take kindly to what they would consider to be interference in their internal affairs. In many cases this is exactly what the government offering an amnesty wo...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con04b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con04a
test
44f6fe50-8b45-4d77-9f85-b1ea4d10a712
Governments have always struggled with the idea of press investigation and freedom of information, claiming Assange is not a journalist is simply a stunt. We know that most governments struggle with the idea of not having control over information and are suspicious of the media. In a pre-Internet age working with a ha...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro02a
test
63d420f7-c353-464a-b73d-7160d2a747dd
The Internet is a free domain and cannot becontrolled by the government. Given that the Internet is used as an international [1] and public space [2] , the government has no right over the information which may be presented via the Internet. In Western liberal democracies, governments are elected on the basis by which...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-con02a
test
9a1f4732-1eca-4d46-8543-7da22ab7a6ec
As an extensive form of media, the Internet should be subject to regulation just as other forms of media are. Under the status quo, states already regulate other forms of media that could be used malevolently. Newspapers and books are subject to censorship [1] , and mediums such as television, film and video receive a...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro04b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro04a
test
438ed233-9b54-4854-98f9-32b62e3a2977
The liberal democratic paradigm is not the only legitimate model of government, a fact that democracies should accept and embrace Ultimately, states’ laws have to be respected. Liberal democracy has not proven to be the end of history as Fukuyama suggested, but is rather one robust system of government among many. Chi...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con02a
test
08747dd7-5782-4569-950b-36f419049331
Defamation While South African Law does allow for freedom of speech, and the constitution is one of the most liberal in the world for protecting such freedoms, it must be measured against the need for responsibility in the use of such freedoms to prevent offence. Whatever one believes about ‘The Spear’ it is clear th...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01a
test
143d81bc-70d0-4664-a2c3-d4881f551fd0
This offer of amnesty serves as a powerful public statement in favour of free speech and rule of law In offering amnesty Western governments make an exceptionally powerful public statement in the international arena, an area in which they already hold great sway as norm-setters. It is a statement that shows that they ...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro03a
test
f160999f-f4b5-4dff-ab12-c749ea3e456d
Even sites that appeared innocent have had a devastating effect on society. Some governments, such as the Vietnamese government [1] , have already seen sufficient cause to ban social networking sites such as Facebook. Recently in the UK, many major cities witnessed devastation and destruction as social networking site...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro03a
test
57e1b6f1-108f-4078-af25-81804eeaff83
Governments have a moral duty to protect its citizens from harmful sites. In recent years, supposedly innocent sites such as social networking sites have been purposely used to harm others. Victims of cyber bullying have even led victims to commit suicide in extreme cases [1] [2] . Given that both physical [3] and psy...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro01a
test
9cba4444-3a41-4249-9f2e-30b03981f2e8
Public Decency Freedom of Speech is something that is highly valued, particularly in a country such as South Africa, where it was in short supply for a large part of its history, but surely for such speech to be worthwhile, it has to be able to convey a message that actually enriches the public domain. Such messages c...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a
test
eaaa9a55-f33a-48cd-8aae-72dcdc02d65d
These people are under serious threat for their pursuit of justice The internet has become the paramount means of voicing dissent within repressive regimes. As the technology regimes have to keep control of their people increases, with access to high-tech surveillance technology adding to their already formidable arse...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro01a
test
4ce913f3-b2c5-48c8-91be-81e128bb3fdf
Masculinity The problem with leaving the painting, the spear, up is that to many young men President Zuma symbolises what excessive wealth can ‘buy’ you. He is the figure head of the nation, the pinnacle of capitalism and masculinity, of which the penis and sex are instrumental in this image. By leaving the painting u...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con04b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con04a
test
57ca09d4-1867-438f-a666-634f4fff3b8c
The government here may legitimately limit ‘free speech’. We already set boundaries on what constitutes ‘free speech’ within our society. For example, we often endorse a ‘balancing act’ [1] an individual may express their beliefs or opinions, but only up to the point where it does not impede the ‘protection of other h...
[{"id": "test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-science-ciidfaihwc-pro02a
test
c658e8fc-5f59-45c0-8ea0-27554b85a4a0
Democracies have an obligation to shield these people and to encourage further dissent The universality of human rights, of the freedom of speech and of due process is all touted as crucial by the world’s democracies. Democratic countries are frequently vocal on the subject of liberty, on the superiority of their syst...
[{"id": "test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-sdiflhrdffe-pro02a
test
12052793-2320-4cf4-89c5-f4a37cd6ad7c
Infantilisation and Prejudice Those who dismiss the reaction to ‘The Spear’ forget the historical context which may trigger the sorts of responses seen to the artwork. [1] South Africa’s past problems can be seen to derive from the gross caricaturing of Black people and Black Men in particular as lascivious, overtly ...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02a
test
bf970583-19cb-4840-be7e-7c298216805d
It’s impossible to police such a law. There is simply no feasible way of enforcing laws against arranged marriages, particularly as it is almost guaranteed that many communities will continue to practice them regardless. It will be impossible to tell whether a marriage has been started by arrangement if the community ...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con01a
test
d9e89c0e-c48c-409c-a3af-424e9caf68ca
Racialised Opposition Some critics of ‘The Spear’ have criticised the artwork on the grounds that it ‘dehumanises’ black people in general [1] and President Zuma in particular and criticises him based upon his personal life rather than policy, using vulgar means to do it. This line of opposition is part of a dog-whist...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a
test
ddca97e4-f787-4a9a-ae6f-69bf9acf58a4
It will cause resentment and make certain communities feel targeted. Arranged marriages are seen as a very important aspect of the identity of lots of Euro-Asian communities. At a time when tensions between non-Muslims and Muslims in Europe are high enough, for example there were protests in London against the film in...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con02a
test
6277d6ba-e0c9-41ad-a790-10f0844b0412
Hand Guns Are Required For Self Defence. Under the status quo handguns are legal. This means that should a criminal initially wish to consider mugging someone he has to consider the possibility that he might be shot should he choose to take this action. A visceral fear of death and injury means that a significant numb...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con01a
test
e9e9cd0c-d1ff-41ad-925f-0bec4a2f8a06
Artistic Freedom A core principle of art is that it should be free from any form of inhibition, as the particular artwork is an expression of the particular views and ideals of the artist. The subject matter in many instances is their own choice; therefore they have the right to say what they want about the subject ma...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a
test
eafbc132-f81c-4bd8-9dbc-19859e8b823a
The DC Handgun ban is inconsistent with other legislation in the U.S. A change in legislation in DC that is markedly different from everywhere else in the U.S. is harmful. Whilst the constitution might be amended to give a specific change for DC, the rest of the U.S. will still be able to bear arms. The point of the A...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con03a
test
98a00733-960d-4549-88a2-45245b25965b
The state should not be allowed to intrude in such personal matters Matters relating to how individuals conduct themselves in a private and consensual environment are arguably not the concern of the state. This extends to how people get married and within which tradition, religion or denomination. European states are ...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-con03a
test
12694239-49c5-40cd-84b4-5939c3f8ebac
The dam would power Africa Only 29% of Sub Saharan Africa’s population has access to electricity. [1] This has immense consequences not just for the economy as production and investment is constrained but also on society. The world bank says lack of electricity affects human rights “People cannot access modern hospita...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-pro01a
test
9fcb019e-aa1a-414c-b008-19fa1f15e9ca
Pluralism and Political Interference The removal of ‘The Spear’ from the Goodman Gallery and the City Press also hints at a threat to pluralism, especially when one considers the political nature of the campaign to have such images removed. While Jacob Zuma attempted to have the image banned in a personal capacity, t...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a
test
1522d243-1a1f-4f3a-850d-90386af77f75
Handguns are Required For Symbolic Reasons As A Defence Against the State Monopoly of Power Handguns are legal in the U.S. for symbolic reasons. In Justice Scalla’s oral argument he stated “isn't it perfectly plausible, indeed reasonable, to assume that since the framers knew that the way militias were destroyed by ty...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-con02a
test
8eab84a3-3557-40ef-ac5a-663046819cfb
Women in arranged marriages in Europe are disproportionately likely to suffer abuse Arranged marriages are often different when practiced in the home countries of many immigrant families in Europe, where women often have networks of friends and relatives to rely on. The danger with allowing arranged marriages to happe...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro03a
test
cf7a1407-1d01-4fed-8f33-e63580fb1836
A handgun ban reduces crime and deaths Aside from the fact that handguns are uniquely dangerous weapons, when the handgun ban was in place in DC, there was a reported decrease in crime in the area. In 1977 the year immediately following the ban the U.S. Conference of Mayors reported robberies, assaults and homicides u...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro03a
test
3e22b8ac-13fc-426d-80d8-efa08f2d75db
Individual Freedom Even if marriages are not made absolutely mandatory, covert family pressure can still propel people into unions where they will be unhappy. This is a form of restricted liberty as the consequences of people rebelling against arranged marriages can include being forced to leave home or suffering stig...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro01a
test
ffa5f0d3-2a2d-4a56-a51c-df8103917e17
Regardless of the views expressed, freedom of speech means that all opinions should be heard. Allowing politicians to regulate what it is acceptable to say – or think – is not something that has a happy history. This isn’t the result of a purely intellectual construct but one of altruistic self-interest; once people s...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con01a
test
3fc711b0-1480-403d-b461-dc9e8a2a1805
Handguns are uniquely dangerous when compared with other weapons Handguns are specifically worse than most other weapons. They are weapons which are both concealable and portable. Shotguns and Rifles can easily be identified from a long distance making it easier to avoid those who are carrying them or conversely for t...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro02a
test
b2e729ed-eb65-4406-98fe-9b746afa4cb3
Integration and the acceptance of Western values are important Arranged marriages have not been a part of the cultures of most European countries for many years now. Part of the reason for this is because ideas about marriage have become more progressive, with people accepting that men and women of any orientation sho...
[{"id": "test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-msgfhwbamec-pro02a
test
cc3d90aa-f140-4c55-9202-fbc921b839a2
Individuals Should Not Have the Right to Bear Arms in DC Under the status quo the state exists to protect the security of its citizens. It does so by maintaining a monopoly of violence with the consent of its citizens. US citizens have been allowed to bear small arms as a symbolic representation of their ability to ri...
[{"id": "test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplglghwbhwd-pro01a
test
32ba1ee5-3a29-456f-97c6-1f123fffe103
Will enable the rebuilding of DRC DR Congo has been one of the most war ravaged countries in the world over the last two decades. The Grand Inga provides a project that can potentially benefit everyone in the country by providing cheap electricity and an economic boost. It will also provide large export earnings; to t...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-pro03a
test
97fabb44-344a-44ec-8662-b261e841b055
Silencing views that are considered offensive is self-defeating and would be detrimental to those attempting to advance gay rights. If freedom of speech is to mean anything then it needs to be a principle that is universally applied. Unless speech represents a direct and immediate threat to public safety then it shoul...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con03a
test
11115f3c-1adf-4ec0-87f7-836d4feb0e97
A dam could make the Congo more usable While the Congo is mostly navigable it is only usable internally. The rapids cut the middle Congo off from the sea. The building of the dams could be combined with canalisation and locks to enable international goods to be easily transported to and from the interior. This would h...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-pro04b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-pro04a
test
8e660a8f-540b-4c80-9287-0a4c26c5c10b
There is no right not to be offended, enforcing what is acceptable to be thought or said places far too much power in the hands of the state. It is impossible to ensure that nobody is ever offended and it is questionable as to whether it is even desirable [1] . There is simply no way of protecting against offence. The...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con02a
test
03ea6d35-80b2-4231-8ca5-d95312ce061e
A dam would damage the environment Dams due to their generation of renewable electricity are usually seen as environmentally friendly but such mega projects are rarely without consequences. The Grand Inga would lower the oxygen content of the lower course of the river which would mean a loss of species. This would not...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-con02a
test
33dc0a24-5156-43ff-9da7-9db0664a6154
Banning religious symbols is just a way of unfairly targeting people. Banning religious symbols could be viewed as just a way of targeting a group of people. In a nutshell, religious symbols would be used as a scapegoat in order to both highlight and blame for problems that are much bigger. Removing the hijab, the Cru...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con01a
test
c2b6c842-9717-402c-aa3f-607915fa7714
Dams displace communities Dams result in the filling of a large reservoir behind the dam because it has raised the level of the water in the case of the Grand Inga it would create a reservoir 15km long. This is not particularly big but the construction would also displace communities. The previous Inga dams also displ...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-con03a
test
afea0fc2-3f7d-4661-b15f-1a108f3fd293
ICC does not have same problems as other legal systems The ICC as a court does not have many of the things that a domestic criminal trial would have in terms of disadvantages of televising. Like all other international tribunals, there is no jury, only a panel of professional judges. Judges are going to be less intimi...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-con01a
test
197e6b7e-063b-44d8-a6ff-66d110226d87
Carbon Trading Schemes The EU ETS is an example of a viable carbon market, it covers thirty countries from the EU as well as Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. Countries within the ETS are using market mechanisms to force domestic emitters to meet national caps as the amount of allowances reduces over time emissions f...
[{"id": "test-environment-chbwtlgcc-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-chbwtlgcc-con01a
test
bbda6bea-d65b-46b9-b726-93f53a3c0af6
Ill-informed prejudice has no place in society. The veneer of religion has been used to justify hatred, prejudice and division and should be confronted. Homophobia is the last respectable prejudice [1] and should be tackled with the same passion and force that others have been, and continue to be, confronted. If the s...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro03a
test
1d30c820-a227-48bf-b45b-75ca0c7dd44b
It is their culture and religion. Religions themselves tend to encompass their own distinctive culture and, to many of their members, this culture and its methods comes before anything secular. For this reason, Muslims should be allowed to wear personal items as it states in the ruling of their religious book to do so...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con04b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con04a
test
e7817ed1-cc90-419a-bb02-9098da0be782
If you ban one thing, you have to ban lots of things. Every religious symbol should be treated equally so as not to cause discrimination. It's just not viable to ban one symbol. If you ban something, for example, as sacred and religious as the Muslim veil, people will then start rallying cries for other things to be b...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con03a
test
12f02271-d646-461c-bbe6-717105cd9580
Broadcasting provides a public record Unlike many other criminal trials, since Nuremberg a key principle of International Criminal Law is that it aims to set a historical record. The events that it deals with are important as they are heinous crimes that change regions forever. A trial helps to get to the bottom of ev...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-con03a
test
6f5c7276-6b0d-41f8-8372-27b9e9b0c177
Open justice – crimes with large numbers of victims The principle of open justice, including the right to a public trial [1] , is enshrined in many legal systems. The best show of commitment to open justice is to allow everyone to watch it, the best method of doing so is for the trial to be televised. This is all the ...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-con02a
test
1423f09f-7a88-4117-81b0-0124bdd59ffa
Religion simply justifies reactionary views which many find offensive. There is no reason for vitriol to be tolerated just because it presents a mask of religion. Views on issues such as abortion, women, and what constitutes an acceptable family expressed by those who are extremely religious are simply bigoted views w...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a
test
1f170c39-50c3-43c7-beb6-b50de9d2c235
Because religion promotes certainty of belief, divinely inspired hatred is easy to use to justify and promote violent actions and discriminatory practices. Free speech must come second when there is the potential for that speech to cause harm. The mantra of “With God on our side” has been used, and continues to be use...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02a
test
8badb764-a42a-4f24-a6b1-7d45793d1e31
An immense boost to DRC’s economy The Grand Inga dam would be an immense boost to the DRC’s economy. It would mean a huge amount of investment coming into the country as almost all the $80 billion construction cost would be coming from outside the country which would mean thousands of workers employed and spending mon...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-pro02a
test
892bde8f-61d8-4c5f-8f3a-93d63f665c83
Religious symbols are personal, therefore, they should not matter to others. At the end of the day, the wearing of religious symbols is the choice of the individual. Many have considered intervention in the practice of religion and symbolism as an intrusion into privacy and individuality. The recent bans on the full M...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-con02a
test
93808482-486a-4eaf-942d-87d72207c3c0
A ban will be ineffective A new legal prohibition on any type of behaviour or conduct can only be set up by investing large amounts of political capital in order to transform vague proposals into a legislative document and then into a fully-fledged law. This expense can only be justified if the ban is effective – if i...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02a
test
0bdd7cf6-19bb-41ae-a679-e2b67470a47c
Unruly defendants can play up to the cameras Televising the trial can create extra incentives for defendants to attempt to disrupt the process. During his trial, Saddam Hussein regularly made outbursts and went on political rants – based on Iraqi law, he was able to examine witnesses after his lawyer. This was not new...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-pro03a
test
11566fc8-73ad-460b-9b54-7f445729f8c1
The cost is too high The Grand Inga is ‘pie in the sky’ as the cost is too immense. At more than $50-100 billion it is more than twice the GDP of the whole country. [1] Even the much smaller Inga III project has been plagued by funding problems with Westcor pulling out of the project in 2009. [2] This much smaller pro...
[{"id": "test-environment-opecewiahw-con04b", "score": 1}]
test-environment-opecewiahw-con04a
test
2eba9b04-b928-4c50-94e8-fef545c42256
A ban will further marginalise young members of impoverished communities Hip hop is an extremely diverse musical genre. Surprisingly, this diversity has evolved from highly minimal series of musical principles. At its most basic, raping consists of nothing more than rhyming verses that are delivered to a beat. This si...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a
test
6a9b4d39-657a-463b-b868-b92063641eb1
Televising turns justice into entertainment Broadcasting trials would be likely to turn the court in to entertainment. The Simpson trial showed how harmful a televised high profile trial can be degenerating into a freak show. The ICC trials are among the most high profile in the world so are likely to be susceptible t...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-pro01a
test
f5a951b5-da57-4c92-a577-02f262288b0c
A ban would be simple to enforce. A ban would be simple to create and enforce. Religious symbols are for the most part meant to be shown therefore it is simple for police or authorities to check that someone is not wearing them. There are many societies that have had bans on a religious symbol in public buildings, for...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro04b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro04a
test
05c64b81-8532-47c6-8b09-4b8fc1d7a48c
Violent imagery can serve different purposes. Calls for a ban on music that references or glorifies violence are frequently based on an overly simplistic understanding of contemporary and popular musical genres. It is instructive that the loudest voices of protest raised against violent content in hip hop and rock mus...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01a
test
ef3a32cc-44f7-48a7-8888-323c18eb3397
Religious symbols cause division within Western society. Religious symbols can be seen as possible tools for fuelling division within society. When some women wear the Hijab it creates pressure on other Muslim women to also cover their heads. Pressure comes both socially from wanting to look like other women in their ...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro03a
test
b62e29c1-8138-4482-a645-5849418159c9
Witnesses might be identified and placed in danger Televising criminal trials may cause a number of problems with witnesses. It may make individuals less likely to give evidence, make them more likely to play to the television audience, or make the already intimidating process of giving evidence in court more so. Also...
[{"id": "test-law-umtlilhotac-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-umtlilhotac-pro02a
test
03825fe5-044d-4c8e-b812-73a8b264c720
Many symbols are seen as a symbol of oppression on women. Religious symbols are seen to, in some cases, increase the equality divide between genders. As an example, the Muslim Hijab is considered by some as a very powerful symbol for the oppression of women, particularly in countries such as Saudi Arabia or Afghanista...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro01a
test
1b566e94-68a0-4407-a0e1-5ce5ab98b1d4
The motion completely undermines the assumption of innocence which accompanies a fair trial. By projecting past convictions on to a new case, this disclosure greatly weakens the presumption of innocence which is the defendant’s right [1] . It is the jury’s duty to form a verdict based on the relevant case, and it shou...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-con01a
test
81d33489-6af3-4c37-99b0-4b196a5b241d
Defending hip hop artists’ right to free speech The intervention of the state is necessary in order to ensure that aggressive forms of hip hop remain accessible only to adults, especially in neighbourhoods and home environments that are not part of a cohesive, caring community. Some degree of public control over the c...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a
test
2da8d87f-edb9-4391-bde9-cdd4df7a8a7a
The disclosure of previous convictions could falsely characterize the defendant. This motion is incredibly dangerous in a variety of ways as not only convictions but also acquittals and other past conduct could then be raised in a court trials. This means that a jury could be informed that somebody had questionable be...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-con03a
test
26c4c2b7-9a71-4198-b22a-5d604dd0564c
Western societies are secularly focused Many societies are founded on secular values that do not permit the sponsorship of any religion by the state. British society aspires to this and has consciously acted to separate religion from state authority with many organisations such as the National Secular Society encourag...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro05b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro05a
test
36a96304-1fe8-4778-a98f-5ab673c6571e
Classification, not censorship We should expect fans of an art form that is subjected to public criticism and vilification to leap to its defence. Some of these aficionados- whether the medium in question is cinema, fine art or pop music- make the case for the value of their favourite mode of expression by overstating...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a
test
d4dff8f8-9653-471c-b845-b887348b2495
Religious symbols cause problems in schools. As well as division in society in general, religious symbols are also a source of division within school environments. The Hijab causes schools many problems. It is potentially divisive in the classroom, marking some children out as different from the others and above the r...
[{"id": "test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-grcrgshwbr-pro02a
test
742b8c9c-d649-4a9e-978e-2860254ed16b
Allowing this motion would lead to a miscarriage of justice. This motion removes the incentive for police to conduct vigorous investigations. Given the increasing pressure on policemen and women to gain convictions [1] , this motion will mean that their best chance of obtaining those convictions is simply to accuse th...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-con04b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-con04a
test
03f740ba-488d-41a5-ad21-b7d29a8ed9b3
Hate speech The enforcement of the laws proposed in this article will be fraught, complex and difficult. However, the difficulty of administering a law is never a good argument for refusing to enforce it. The censorship of the written word ended in England with the Lady Chatterley and Oz obscenity trials, but this li...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a
test
9f3644c1-334c-4df2-976c-83b7c6438628
This is a victory for democracy – a precious Filipino value - clear majorities in both houses and in the wider public support it Opposition have conveniently glossed over one critical issue in this debate – that the RH Bill has significant popular support [i] . It also, as has been demonstrated that a majority of elec...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con01a
test
7ba5aa38-7db0-4bed-abfe-e88df73a7b56
We already recognise that we cannot place complete trust in juries. Although we recognise that juries can provide valuable insight and represent the will of the general public in court cases [1] (and especially the communities in which the crimes occurred [2] ), there is also recognition that juries can be subject to ...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-con02a
test
d02e7506-1663-4a69-bdb0-d0740c102005
Argument One: Contact leads to the dissemination of values There is certainly some evidence to suggest the view that trade with a country can benefit human rights as increased wealth provides many with more choice and better standards of living. [i] Certainly that argument has been made by governments and multi-nation...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a
test
921aa164-c328-476a-87a7-1abfca8724ec
Any body of values that claims to respect the rights of the individual must recognise the right of a woman to choose Even the doctrines of the Church accepts that pregnancy is not, in and of itself, a virtue – there is no compulsion to maximise the number of pregnancies; there is simply a disagreement about how they s...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con03a
test
dcae7719-7e96-4930-b80e-10f086703d14
The appropriate setting for sexual relations is within marriage, contraception encourages pre-marital sex The population of the Philippines are overwhelmingly Catholic, it seems reasonable to accept that many, if not most, accept the teaching of the Church that safe sex is married sex. Appropriate sexual relations bet...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro01a
test
9f8fe6ca-c997-4bcd-819c-21c8f32d3651
Defendants who are innocent will be protected This motion could allow innocent defendants to mount a stronger case. This is because, if allowed, the previous convictions of prosecution witnesses would be admitted as evidence. In this case, if a prosecution witness falsely claims good character in opposition to the def...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro04b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro04a
test
d064b00e-8dd0-498a-97c8-8c6e8f879cea
There are clear and proven benefits to the health of the Filipino families, especially women Both sides of this debate have spoken about the need to respect the rights and lives of women. It is, however, difficult to see how exactly opponents of the legislation reconcile this with their actions. Decades’ worth of rese...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-con02a
test
128e0f39-20ce-4c76-a6e2-55104f0f038c
The current system is unfairly weighted in favour of criminals. It is unfair that those who repeatedly re-offend should be treated in the same manner as those who have committed one offence; a singular offence could mark a mistake or accident in the defendant’s choices, but repeated criminal acts mark a habit and a la...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro01a
test
5b26945c-b50a-4e26-9882-845aa18a8a85
Jurors are already aware of information which might ‘bias’ their verdict. Jurors are frequently affected by media coverage of particular cases, which makes it almost impossible for them to remain impartial in the idealistic way which opposition naively believes possible. This creates a situation where the jury may be ...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro03a
test
b61fc40e-7981-4419-aef2-d03ef2067805
The bill violates the Philippine values of harmony and respect Perhaps the most important values in the Philippines are social harmony and respect for the family. [i] The Reproductive Health bill undermines both. Allowing contraception will take away a psychological barrier that prevents pre-marital or casual sex and ...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro03a
test
dcb6128a-8fb5-4663-958c-7194eff71ed2
‘Separation of town and gown’ There are two parties involved in this interaction, the state and the university. To pretend that is an entirely one way process is to ignore reality. Contrary to the belief of many Senior Common Rooms, states do not exist for the convenience of universities. Indeed universities quite hap...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a
test
59df637f-8e73-4bf8-bc06-4e0d94988ee0
Maintaining the value of the degree Employers and others expect certain degrees to mean certain things; they are more than just an expensive badge. In the case of elite western universities part of what that means is a critical approach to the world and the willingness to challenge ideas, regardless of the authority t...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a
test
9b33a519-42b9-426e-85eb-d6ab1f999e71
Universities should exchange ideas not impose them Of all possible institutions, for a university to suggest that it is not open to defending its ideas rather than insisting that they be artificially imported seems counter-intuitive. As Asian and European intellectual traditions increasingly interact as a result of ec...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03a
test
6895cc4f-ebfe-49b6-8eeb-c61b03318d6a
Occasional disclosure of convictions leads to an inconsistent justice system. At present in Britain, some previous convictions may be disclosed if they bear a striking resemblance to the case at trial, if the defendant falsely claims to be of good character, or if they attack the character of a prosecution witness [1]...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro05b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro05a
test
bd98d22f-9f04-4df8-97f6-43fa06848b7f
The academic tradition of the West The growth of universities as beacons of free speech has been a fundamental part of their history in the West; notably during the renaissance, reformation and enlightenment. The democratisation of that process with the expansion of the university sector in recent decades is merely th...
[{"id": "test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01b", "score": 1}]
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01a
test
da130153-43e8-4418-98d9-0c1a1ab18b39
Poor families would be helped far more by investment in education and healthcare This has been an urban and political obsession from the outset. The idea that the hungry and homeless need condoms more than food and shelter is clearly absurd. The poor would be better helped through “accessible education, better hospita...
[{"id": "test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-cmrsgfhbr-pro02a
test
c71f8037-a8f3-4516-8b92-04c346dab7ed
Unrestricted Coca production would increase the availability of cocaine Cocaine can be readily extracted from the coca leaf. In 1992 the World Health Organization’s Expert Committee on Drug Dependence (ECDD) undertook a ‘prereview’ of coca leaf at its 28th meeting. The 28th ECDD report concluded that, “the coca leaf i...
[{"id": "test-law-thgglcplgphw-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-law-thgglcplgphw-con01a
test
cf03c2bd-5ff5-4765-acdd-5b897ace1fc7
Juries need to have all the information possible in order to reach a fair verdict. It is nonsensical to withhold evidence from a jury that might be necessary for them to reach an accurate verdict. Just because their verdict might be more prone to conviction rather than acquittal does not necessarily mean that this is ...
[{"id": "test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro02b", "score": 1}]
test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro02a
test
816f7a9e-79db-426c-b974-c2d47e2ba952
There is no proven cause of harm and parents routinely make medical decisions for children to give their consent or otherwise Circumcision is akin, in many ways, to vaccination; a routine and simple procedure with miniscule risks and compelling probable benefits. We acknowledge the right of parents to take these decis...
[{"id": "test-religion-wcprrgrhbmi-con01b", "score": 1}]
test-religion-wcprrgrhbmi-con01a
test